It's Winter Break! Bwog will be moving in slow motion.

Columbia and Graciela Chichilnisky: A Legal History

Meet Graciela Chichilnisky, an econ professor who was just awarded a $200,000 settlement from Columbia, which is roughly the amount of your tuition or any one product from Nussbaum & Wu. She has been suing Columbia on and off since 1990 (back when some of you Terrible 12s weren't even born!), claiming gender discrimination and unequal pay, claims that were also previously settled in 1995 for $500,000. As a result of the earlier suit, Chichilnisky's salary was raised from $60,000 to $110,000.

So then, in 2000, Chichilnisky stopped teaching math and started working exclusively in the econ. department because Columbia was terminating the United Nations Educational and Cultural Organization, which she had chaired. She found that her office in the Mathemetics building was hers no longer. "It's almost impossible to believe this is happening," she told Spec. "The destruction and removal of one's office space, without notice is like a violation of one's physical space." Columbia repsponded that the school is crunched for space and that Chichilnisky wasn't making full use of her math office.

She filed another lawsuit claiming that her pay was less than that of her male counterparts, and that in dismantling her office, Columbia "has retaliated against her by breaching the terms of the settlement." In turn, Columbia filed counterclaims, charging that Chichilnisky had a secret second job -- she was the founder and CEO of a multimillion dollar corporation -- and that she never disclosed that to anyone in Low. According to CU, this was a breach of the previous settlement agreement.

Anyway, she circulated something called the "Columbia Injustice Petition," which expressed outrage that Chichilnisky's office was taken away from her, and also said that Columbia's proposed solution of setting her up with an office in the Interchurch Center was a no-go. It was signed by 72 of her students and peers.

Which pretty much brings us up to speed to this June, when Chichilnisky sued Columbia for 11 million for breaching the terms of the previous settlement by denying her equal pay and the aforementioned office space. Of the ruling, the plaintiff said: "The exact number isn't as important as the principle that it was a substantial amount of money that the university had to pay. And that has to do with who is right and who is wrong."


Posted by ugh : #1 · reply · track
July 1, 2008 at 12:17 PM
too many collagen injections and too many face lifts.
Posted by I wonder : #2 · reply · track
July 1, 2008 at 12:19 PM
what real feminists think about the fact that their movement has turned into an excuse to sue your employer at any and every opportunity on the grounds of sexism...
Posted by wtf : #3 · reply · track
July 1, 2008 at 12:33 PM
another example of how much the columbia math department sucks...
Posted by man : #4 · reply · track
July 1, 2008 at 12:40 PM (from campus)
FACT: Women are evil.
Posted by yes : #5 (in reply to #4) · reply · track
July 1, 2008 at 12:42 PM
hahahahaha

so true
Posted by confused : #6 · reply · track
July 1, 2008 at 1:04 PM (from campus)
I don't understand why she wants the money.
Posted by ... : #7 · reply · track
July 1, 2008 at 2:03 PM
good lord.
Posted by ... : #8 · reply · track
July 1, 2008 at 2:15 PM
what a bitch!
Posted by yikes : #9 · reply · track
July 1, 2008 at 2:27 PM
holy collagen injections and cheek implants!
Posted by i assumed : #10 · reply · track
July 1, 2008 at 2:35 PM (from campus)
MTF?
Posted by well... : #11 · reply · track
July 1, 2008 at 2:58 PM
i think we know what what she did with the money... those lips are out of control.
Posted by ugh : #12 · reply · track
July 1, 2008 at 2:59 PM
stupid woman. Is this what happens in an economic slowdown? Sue Columbia to pay your plastic surgeon?

I've never heard of her before, anyone been taught by her?
Posted by not too stupid : #13 (in reply to #12) · reply · track
July 1, 2008 at 3:53 PM (from campus)
she only wrote the kyoto protocols
Posted by Apple Nifty : #14 · reply · track
July 1, 2008 at 3:54 PM
Tracing the money, I guess you could say that is the true face of Columbia.
Posted by i think : #15 (in reply to #13) · reply · track
July 1, 2008 at 4:42 PM
you just proved #12's point.

can I call her 'Chinchilla'?
Posted by aghast : #16 · reply · track
July 1, 2008 at 4:54 PM (from campus)
jiminy crickets that woman is ugly!
Posted by anonymous : #17 (in reply to #6) · reply · track
July 1, 2008 at 7:23 PM
This comment has been deleted.
Posted by !!!!!!! : #18 · reply · track
July 1, 2008 at 7:41 PM (from campus)
Can only wait to see what she sues Columbia for when she's finally terminated...

btw, feel free to send her an email (see above link). It's public information from her website, therefore *NOT* against BOWG policy.
Posted by ewwww : #19 · reply · track
July 1, 2008 at 7:49 PM
YUCK. just look at her face. that woman needs to spend less money on plastic surgery and stop complaining.

Posted by milton : #20 · reply · track
July 1, 2008 at 7:59 PM
her office was taken away... was her stapler taken too? :-)
Posted by students : #21 · reply · track
July 1, 2008 at 8:24 PM (from campus)
signed her petition? gee, not sketchy at all.
Posted by ddddd : #22 · reply · track
July 1, 2008 at 10:29 PM
This comment has been deleted.
Posted by wow : #23 · reply · track
July 1, 2008 at 10:34 PM (from campus)
she's bitching that her SECOND office was taking away 9assumeg she already had one for the econ dept.)? Really? How about, you know, everyone else who can't get space at all, much less a second office?!
Posted by hah : #24 (in reply to #20) · reply · track
July 1, 2008 at 10:58 PM
love it
Posted by umm : #25 · reply · track
July 1, 2008 at 11:21 PM
BWOG, way to find a photo of cross-dressed Chappelle.
Posted by P.S. : #26 · reply · track
July 1, 2008 at 11:22 PM
I'M RIIIIIICH BIIIIIYAAAAAAAATCH!
Posted by great... : #27 · reply · track
July 2, 2008 at 12:23 AM
So this is what our tuition money is going towards? Great.
Posted by well... : #28 (in reply to #27) · reply · track
July 2, 2008 at 1:42 AM
because of her, south lawn will sadly only be re-sodded 4 times this year (instead of our normal 15).
Posted by huh? : #29 · reply · track
July 2, 2008 at 4:09 AM
"Columbia was terminating the United Nations Educational and Cultural Organization, which she had chaired"

good god, columbia killed unesco? who knew it was so powerful and sinister?
Posted by hahaha : #30 (in reply to #29) · reply · track
July 2, 2008 at 10:31 AM
HAHAHAHA
Posted by I had her : #31 · reply · track
July 2, 2008 at 4:03 PM
She was an awful, awful teacher. She made the TA do a ridiculous amount of busy work and never really taught us anything.

I think she's married to a professor in Environmental Science. Look into it, BWOG!
Posted by well... : #32 · reply · track
July 2, 2008 at 4:44 PM (from campus)
anybody ever have one of the other two tenured profs in the econ department? they're not so hot either. padma desai and alessandra cassella have been the 2 lowest paid people in the econ department every year since 1996.
Posted by Alum : #33 · reply · track
July 2, 2008 at 5:33 PM
"Columbia was terminating the United Nations Educational and Cultural Organization, which she had chaired."

As its name suggests, UNESCO is a program of the UN, not Columbia. Columbia couldn't terminate UNESCO even if it wanted to. What actually happened was that Columbia terminated a program which UNESCO funded and which Prof. Chichilnisky (who is the UNESCO Professor of Resource Management) directed.
Posted by Alum : #34 (in reply to #32) · reply · track
July 2, 2008 at 5:54 PM
There are about 25 tenured professors in the department. Even if you were referring only to women, you forgot Janet Currie (the department chair) and Serena Ng. There's also Stephanie Schmitt-Grohe, a new senior hire from Duke.

Lena Edlund may recently have earned tenure, too; if not, it's surely just a matter of time.
Posted by dear alum... : #35 · reply · track
July 2, 2008 at 6:49 PM (from campus)
padma desai and alessandra cassella, the two women (aside from chichilnisky) to have tenure in the econ department until 2003-2004, consistently earned the two lowest salaries of all tenured professors (and continue to do so). this is including later hires, younger hires, less published hires, all of whom were male until 2003-2004. so the econ department provides one of MANY examples of women faculty members consistently being paid less than the males. and if you're looking for another case in which a woman got mad enough to sue, check out Joy Hirsch.

if you're trying to suggest Columbia doesn't have problems with both the ratio of male to female faculty ACROSS THE UNIVERSITY, not just within specific departments, look at the American Association of University Professors' recent report on gender discrimination within the Ivy League from 2006.

[external link to www.aaup.org]
Posted by Alum : #36 (in reply to #35) · reply · track
July 2, 2008 at 7:52 PM
All I did was point out a factual error in your earlier post. You said there were only three women with tenure in the department, and I pointed out that there are at least six. That was the extent of my comment. I didn't make any of the other claims you attribute to me, and am not "trying to suggest" any of them either.

I have no information about what the professors in that department earn. I'm not sure how you do or why you feel it is appropriate to reveal this (presumably confidential) information to the world.

I do have one other comment: as far as I know, Casella was the most recent member of the department promoted to full professor from within. It is not surprising that she would make less money than those who are more senior. It is also quite common for external hires -- even those who arrive as full professors but were junior faculty at their old jobs -- to be paid more than a newly-promoted member who had stayed put. Such incentives are what lead people to change jobs. That men Columbia has hired since 2003-2004 make more than Prof. Casella does not imply discrimination. What might would be if they also make more than Profs. Currie, Ng and Schmitt-Grohe, after adjusting for everyone's respective level of experience and degree of accomplishment. Do they?
Posted by Bollocks : #37 (in reply to #35) · reply · track
July 2, 2008 at 8:43 PM (from campus)
are you actually trying to tell me that Padma Desai and co. are paid less because they are women?

FOR FUCK'S SAKE! SUSAN ELMES IS THE HEAD OF THE ECONOMICS DEPT YOU TWERP. SHE IS A WOMAN!

No, the reason Padma is probably paid less is because they probably were forced to give her a job to retain Jagdish. That's not to say she's a bad professor, just probably surplus to Columbia's requirements.
Posted by Hey now : #38 (in reply to #37) · reply · track
July 2, 2008 at 10:20 PM
Watch it with the Desai bashing. She's been one of my favorite professors at the university so far, and she's sharper than you think. Possibly not the world's most exciting lecturer, but she has an unsurpassed understanding of transition economies, and is by all means an expert in her own right.

My guess is, if she is really paid "less" than the norm, it's because her contract was negotiated a long time ago. If she hasn't renegotiated for cost of living increases, as often happens when people are perfectly happy with their salaries, she might make less than someone who came on board only recently.

This whole argument is nonsense, anyway. You can't prove any kind of discrimination with a sample of a half dozen people, but New York's employment discrimination laws are quite liberal, so the mere appearance of discrepancy, however justified, is perhaps reason enough to settle this kind of whining.
Posted by yound alum : #39 (in reply to #37) · reply · track
July 3, 2008 at 3:28 PM
I took two classes with Susan Elmes. She is a nice woman, she is not the head of the econ. department.
Posted by Alum : #40 (in reply to #37) · reply · track
July 3, 2008 at 3:29 PM
Susan Elmes is not "the head of the Economics dept", even if you write it in all caps. She isn't even a tenure-track member of the faculty. She is a lecturer and the department's director of undergraduate studies. That's an important position, but not nearly as important as being chair.

As I mentioned in post #34, the real chair is Janet Currie. That the chair is a woman supports (without proving) your argument about who has power in the department, but it undercuts (without disproving) your argument about who is a twerp.

[external link to www.columbia.edu]
Posted by this prof is : #41 · reply · track
July 5, 2008 at 6:00 PM
someone's mom. try a little decency.
Posted by Global cooling? : #42 · reply · track
July 10, 2008 at 5:19 PM
Apparently she's a sore loser in a climate debate.

[external link to planetgore.nationalreview.com]

Posted by Sophia Lamar? : #43 · reply · track
October 25, 2008 at 3:01 PM
Wow. For a moment, before reading the actual post, I thought maybe this woman was transgendered, and the photos were a "before and after" sequence.

After reading the story, I like my initial approach better.
Name:
Email:
Reply to:

Describe this color in one lowercase word.
37 °F, Wintry Mix

Search

About Us

Bwog is compiled by the staff of The Blue and White, Columbia University's undergraduate magazine.

Contact Us

Please send tips to bwgossip@columbia.edu.

Questions or concerns? Email bweditors@columbia.edu.

Bwog is always looking for new writing talent. Email bwog@columbia.edu.

In Print

Our Favorite Comments

Generic Asshole: [read]
"Ew! How could you ever go to [popular Columbia spot]? It's overpriced and so fake! For REAL [service/product]..."
good analysis: [read]
"Dspar. But you know what, I think the real reason there was a crash is because there are far too few..."

Bwogroll

Technical

Our headlines are syndicated through Atom. This site is powered by the Publicate Content Management System, which is available for free.

Events

01/10/2009


Apply now and keep everyone updated on the artistic pulse of the Columbia campus! Postcrypt Art Gallery is looking for a dedicated webmaster to maintain the official Postcrypt site, www.postcrypt.info. Please e-mail jenny@postcrypt.info with your name, year and school, experience, and statement of interest.

The application deadline is January 10, 2009.


01/24/2009

Contact email: helvidius@columbia.edu

Publish that senior thesis! In its 20th year of publication, the Journal of Politics & Society is inviting submissions for its 2009 edition, which will be distributed in Barnes & Noble and Borders. Please email essays to helvidius@columbia.edu or visit http://www.helvedius.org
for more info. Deadline: January 24, 2009, all disciplines welcome.


01/26/2009

Contact email: cujh@columbia.edu

Positions on the editorial board are competitive, and choices are made by a committee of current editorial board members. To apply, send the following materials to cujh@columbia.edu with the subject line: Prospective Editor Application

Include your name, year, and majors and specializations;

A list of courses taken in the history department, or related courses relevant to the field of history (Philosophy of History; Historical Sociology, etc);

A writing sample of 5 to 7 pages, double-spaced, 12 point font dealing with a historical topic; it may be an excerpt from a larger paper, include a brief abstract if necessary;

An estimate of your availability for the Spring 2009 Semester; include other commitments and positions, and your ability to commit to the extensive reading and editing that a position on the editorial board requires.

The DEADLINE for all applications is JANUARY 26th, but we encourage you to prepare your application and send it right away. Email it with writing sample attached to: cujh@columbia.edu


02/01/2009

Contact email: periwynkle@gmail.com


Do you like to read and write about books, attend literary events/exhibitions, and frequent cafés and bookstores for readings by authors and poets? If you answered yes to any part of the above question, you should write for Spectator Books! My name is Yin Yin Lu, and I am the new Spectator A&E Books Editor. There are many benefits and inimitable opportunities for Books writers besides being able to see your name in print: interviewing all sorts of published writers, from debut novelists to Nobel Peace Prize winners, attending events at the NYPL, Symphony Space, book festivals, and museums for free, and getting free review copies of books before they are released! Last semester, for instance, I interviewed Lytton Smith and Karen Russell, both published graduates of the Columbia MFA program, attended a talk with critics James Wood and Daniel Mendelsohn at the NYPL, and heard Malcolm Gladwell speak at the New Yorker Festival.

Besides being exposed to these exciting opportunities, another reason you should write for Spectator Books is that it is not a long-term commitment - you can contribute as often or as little as you like. You can start your own column, write a recurring feature, or submit an article once every few weeks (or once the entire semester). Moreover, articles are flexible in terms of length and style, depending on whether they are features, reviews, or pieces for the Eye (Spectator's weekly arts and features magazine). Or you can post reviews of any length or style anytime you want on Spectacle, A&E's new and amazing blog.

There really are no obligations to being a Spec Books writer besides actually writing the articles that you want to. I will be sending e-mails with pitches and other information every week, and holding biweekly meetings at the Spec office, but those are not mandatory and are just an opportunity for me to assign pitches and meet my writers.

Completely enticed? Mildly interested? Still uncertain and would like more information? Whatever the case, e-mail me at periwynkle@gmail.com.


02/09/2009

Contact email: cufilmproductions@columbia.edu

Columbia Undergraduate Film Productions is launching our inaugural Production Season to write and produce original short films for our Film Festival!

CUFP Production Season will consist of intensive Screenwriters' Workshops and Directors' Workshops to offer you full creative and logistic support from your peers as you make your films on campus! We are looking for talented writers and directors who are passionate about film to create fresh, interesting material for our film festival.

Ideal candidates will be enthusiastic about film, dedicated to the workshop process, and excited to work on short films in a CUFP workshop setting. Workshops will be late Sunday afternoons and some Monday evenings.

The DEADLINE for Writers' Applications is Friday January 23.
The DEADLINE for Directors' Applications is Monday February 9

All Applicants: Send an e-mail with your name, e-mail, phone number, and school and class information to CUFPproductionseason@gmail.com. Please write a short personal statement (why are you interested in CUFP Production Season? How will you benefit from the workshop process?). Make sure to include all relevant experience with film and writing and/or directing.

**Writers: Please attach a screenwriting sample in Microsoft Word format. Writing sample should be maximum 5 pgs and should give us an idea of your narrative style and genre interest. It does not have to be the short film you will work on in workshop, but if it is not please include pitches/ideas for a short film you would like to workshop.


02/15/2009

Contact email: rhapsody@columbia.edu


Rhapsody in Blue, Columbia's urban affairs journal, having successfully, if belatedly gotten its first semester magazines in hand, is going to try again.

We're back to North America this semester. We need pitches from you. We want thoughtful, interesting, fun pieces that say something about cities. What are you interested in writing about? The first step is to send us a pitch--a paragraph about what you want to talk about, how will you do it? Pitches are due February 15. You'll hear from us if it's a go and drafts due a month later.

Old issues are on our website if you'd like to see more. Great opportunity to publish ideas from class, etc.

Send an email by us with any questions. Our FIRST MEETING for anyone interested in learning more about writing, editing, web or layout will be Wed, JAN 28, at 7:30, Broadway Piano Lounge. Also stay tuned for the study abroad blog, which should be going somewhere this semester. Let us know if you're interested in that as well.


01/6/2010

Contact email: bwog@columbia.edu

Email your event ads to bwog@columbia.edu.


Lost and Found

Lost (or found) an item? Email bwog@columbia.edu.