It's Winter Break! Bwog will be moving in slow motion.

Facebook is not your friend: a word to the wise

In which Ashish Kundra, bringer of news from around the net, passes on a friendly warning.

facebookA few months ago, Microsoft handed Facebook a $240 million wad of cash. Microsoft's new equity boosted Facebook's estimated value to $15 billion (by comparison, that's three times Monster.com's market cap of $4.8 billion). At the moment, Facebook's ad revenues don't come close to a $15 billion dollar value, so there's something up their sleeves that we probably don't know about. We do know that they will be racing to justify that ambitious valuation by doing some more edgy—and profitable—stuff Here are a few things I've noticed or heard of unfolding on Facebook.

Newsfeed Owns You: The newsfeed was designed to increase the time of the average visit. Clearly, increasing this number means is directly increasing ad revenue. And guess what? Just weeks after launching, Newsfeed doubled the average visit time for Facebook users. Hot damn. Makes you wonder how they do it?

The content that shows up on your Newsfeed is selected to keep you on the site. That means, either you have found these people interesting in the past, or other people have found this stuff really interesting. Think about it next time you login. The people you stalk will probably show up more often than not.

Gifts are for charity. For now. Facebook invented the notion of a virtual gift and has done extremely well with it. For the time being, it seems to be all for charity, but Facebook's intentions are far from philanthropic.

When you buy a gift for a dollar (or buy an ad), you have the option of saving your credit card info with your account info. This is a BIG DEAL. Heard of Amazon's One Click Checkout? I am sure we will one day see Facebook-sponsored stores like GAP complete with a One Click Checkout. Gotta stay fly.

Skimming off the top
: Speaking of Amazon, Facebook got in bed with the company on its Marketplace Book Exchange. When you fill in the ISBN of whatever book you are looking for, Facebook readily points you towards a link to Amazon. This is because they see anywhere from 4% to 10% in referrals from that book you purchase.

Targeted Advertising:
Every 10 or 20 times I log in, I see the same Facebook ad for Union Square Ventures - a venture capital firm based in New York. A technology VC firm would probably be smart enough not to waste time advertising to all the kids at Columbia. But this is the perfect example of Facebook's recently-launched advertising platform: in my profile, "start ups" is listed as one of my interests. And since Facebook is getting paid per click, they allow advertisers to target their ads with user's personal profile content. It's kind of like Adwords--but we're talking about our personal information here.

What are these applications about? Be careful when you install an application. It is too easy to install an application, you're giving away a lot of information, and the application developer can pull all of your personal data from your profile. They can also pull a ton of data from your friends' profiles. And here's the real danger: anyone can develop a Facebook application and launch it. There are sites that will even do it for you. So with a decent application name and a cute picture, a developer could compile a lot of personal data very quickly, which can be used for all kinds of identity theft. And since it's an open platform, Facebook cannot place any technological constraints on this data (they do place legal constraints on it, however).

I think we will eventually see a lot of really useful applications developed. For the time being, a lot of cheesy applications aim to gain tons of users and sell their adspace. Others want to make money through less legitimate ways—this one gets paid every time they get you to download a worm that will then send information from your desktop to advertisers.

Takeaway point: as much as Facebook "friends" aren't necessarily real friends, Facebook itself is no pal either. Treat it like the acquaintance you enjoy once in a while, and watch out for its tricks.

Posted by this : #1 · reply · track
January 10, 2008 at 10:09 PM
is good advice.

a bit paranoid, but totally right on.
Posted by Very well done : #2 · reply · track
January 10, 2008 at 10:25 PM
Kudos to you, Ashish.

Now, let's wait and watch what the trolls have to say about this.
Posted by wtf : #3 · reply · track
January 10, 2008 at 10:29 PM
What is "c.r.e.a.m.," why is it a tag, how does it reference anything in this article??
Posted by why is this : #4 · reply · track
January 10, 2008 at 10:30 PM
article's author frequently stoned?

he's been smoking a wee bit too much ashish!
Posted by you see ads? : #5 · reply · track
January 10, 2008 at 10:45 PM
sucker. use adblock.
Posted by C.R.E.A.M. : #6 · reply · track
January 10, 2008 at 10:50 PM
is Cash Rules Everything Around Me.

and it is relevant to everything, all the time.

Listen to the Wu, fool!
Posted by Ashish, : #7 · reply · track
January 10, 2008 at 10:59 PM
well done man, well done.
Posted by get the money : #8 (in reply to #6) · reply · track
January 10, 2008 at 11:15 PM
dollar dollar bill yo
Posted by this : #9 · reply · track
January 10, 2008 at 11:41 PM
is why i have no facebook applications. It's scary how much info you can grab with only a rudimentary knowledge of programming.
Posted by shocked : #10 · reply · track
January 11, 2008 at 12:40 AM
facebook's newsfeed works to show me the stories that i'll probably be interested in?!?!? and it advertises things to me that i'm probably interested in too?!?!? this is awful!!!! I hate it when a website uses information that I give it to direct my attention towards things that I've told it I like...what assholes.
Posted by annoyed : #11 · reply · track
January 11, 2008 at 12:58 AM
oh great job bwog! such investigative reporting!
Posted by Seriously! : #12 (in reply to #10) · reply · track
January 11, 2008 at 1:40 AM
Also, shame on Facebook for attempting to make money! What do they think they are, a business or something?
Posted by you guys : #13 · reply · track
January 11, 2008 at 1:56 AM
comments 10-12, are idiots. people are selling your private information without your knowledge and using it to sell you even more things. that's not cool! why would you criticize someone for pointing that out to your dumb ass? you clearly don't understand how important this is to know.
Posted by Right, : #14 (in reply to #13) · reply · track
January 11, 2008 at 7:33 AM
and that's exactly why I don't put anything overly personal on Facebook, which has been my policy since I got a profile. I also very rarely install applications. Instead of being pissed off at the Facebook developers for doing their job, I take the initiative to be responsible for my information. If all of this freaks you out so much, you should cancel your account. That would be the way to stay 100% safe.
Posted by Fuck : #15 · reply · track
January 11, 2008 at 9:27 AM
Facebook. Deactivate your profiles and keep in touch through phones and e-mail. I feel free.
Posted by Clever : #16 (in reply to #14) · reply · track
January 11, 2008 at 11:54 AM
You're so clever. I guess you don't have Gmail either then? Or do you send your emails in p-language?
Posted by cancelling : #17 (in reply to #14) · reply · track
January 11, 2008 at 12:19 PM
your account in no way obligates facebook to delete the information it has stored about you. In fact, if you "delete" your profile, and choose to reestablish it later, it will magically be restored to its original condition. How do you think this happens, profile restoration fairies?
Posted by ... : #18 · reply · track
January 11, 2008 at 1:58 PM
ashish is for hashish ;)

just messin with you buddy haha
Posted by ... : #19 (in reply to #18) · reply · track
January 11, 2008 at 2:00 PM
but a follow up for people who don't know the author...... he's a fucking genius who is eventually going to have one of his business ideas take off after which you will all be working for him... the dude runs marathons
Posted by fyi : #20 · reply · track
January 11, 2008 at 2:52 PM
the "gifts" were only for charity during the first month (when the $$ went to the Susan B. Komen foundation). Now I believe they're for profit.
Posted by Michael Scott : #21 (in reply to #17) · reply · track
January 11, 2008 at 7:00 PM
Then I'll stay off the grid.
Posted by Won't help : #22 (in reply to #21) · reply · track
January 11, 2008 at 11:05 PM
The Zuckerberg already KNOWS YOU.
Posted by Cool Man : #23 · reply · track
January 12, 2008 at 4:17 AM
when does school start again? the 22nd?
Posted by i see it like this : #24 · reply · track
January 12, 2008 at 5:43 AM
yeah sure, the beacon stuff is really kinda creepy. but beyond that, the targeting stuff is no more evil than what gmail does. same level of privacy invasion, just more data and perhaps a bit more sophistication.

do i really care what is done in with my data in _aggregate_ form? not really. this sort of data collection and analysis has been going on for decades. do i care if they use my personal data as an input for an algorithm for selecting ads and or personalizing stuff? no, not really.

the only time i'd care would be if they started selling off my data with personal information attached. i really don't think they think they could get away with that. they'd be caught and humiliated in the court of public opinion in no time flat.

also, i don't see why you care about credit card numbers. if you're worried about facebook using credit cards as a personal identifier of sorts for exchanging data with third parties, don't be. visa, mastercard and amex all have very strict rules as to what credit card numbers can be used for. sharing credit card transaction data and using card numbers as unique identifiers across merchants is expressly prohibited.

that said, i do agree with the general sentiment of your article. while facebook may appear to be friendly, they are indeed a business. and a business run by a self centered egotistical jackass from harvard at that (putting your name at the bottom of every webpage... come on now.). it's unfortunate, zuckerberg is such a tool he's giving west coast tech entrepreneurs a bad name.

ps. my profile has no mention of startups, but i see that vc firm ad all the time.
Posted by meh : #25 (in reply to #19) · reply · track
January 12, 2008 at 10:55 AM
"he's a fucking genius who is eventually going to have one of his business ideas take off"

If he does, will he try to make a profit?

running marathons =/= success in business. A lot of unsuccessful people run marathons.
Posted by interesting : #26 · reply · track
January 12, 2008 at 12:09 PM
This piece is very informative, but what about the REAL Facebook problems??

1. Getting invited to events by friends at schools that are absolutely nowehere near where you are.

2. Invitations to be a virtual zombie, vampire, werewolf, pirate, or any other sort of mystical being.

3. That Facebook allows the creation of groups such as "Columbia [Newest Freshman Class Here] is ready to party!!!!" Yes, they are highly amusing, but at what cost?!

4. Gifts of eggs that hatch things that do not normally come from eggs. And most other gifts. Why would you send me a crescent roll?? If you were really my friend, you would get me a real crescent roll. Now that's charity. Just sayin.

Most of these have more to do with bad friend etiquette than with Facebook itself. Still, it would be nice if Facebook took a stand against bad friend etiquette someday, because sometimes defriending people is not an option.
Posted by meh : #27 · reply · track
January 12, 2008 at 2:48 PM
don't have a facebook. when is this internet fad going to end?
Posted by "Anonymous" : #28 · reply · track
January 12, 2008 at 5:24 PM
"And since Facebook is getting paid per click, they allow advertisers to target their ads with user's personal profile content. It's kind of like Adwords--but we're talking about our personal information here."

Umm... nothing is personal or private when you share it will 300 of your closest "friends" on the Internet. If you don't want the ads, unplug your computer.
Posted by wow : #29 · reply · track
January 12, 2008 at 7:49 PM
i actually didn't know a lot of that information, especially about the newsfeed targeting. neat story.
Posted by ... : #30 (in reply to #25) · reply · track
January 12, 2008 at 11:00 PM
alright, tell yourself that fatty

i was just trying to say something nice about the guy after rhyming his name with hashish... give me a break hahaha
Posted by chyea : #31 · reply · track
January 13, 2008 at 12:54 AM
no wonder the person i've been stalking shows up so much on my homepage?!

article was sick. thanks
Posted by It'll end : #32 (in reply to #27) · reply · track
January 13, 2008 at 3:40 AM
when the cell phone and bottled water fads end
Posted by damn : #33 (in reply to #32) · reply · track
January 13, 2008 at 3:18 PM
damn.

anyway, you can always take this article further into the creepy by posting excerpts from facebook's terms of service:

"By posting User Content to any part of the Site, you automatically grant… worldwide license (with the right to sublicense) to use, copy… and distribute such User Content for any purpose…. You may remove your User Content from the Site at any time...If you choose to remove your User Content, the license granted above will automatically expire, however you acknowledge that the Company may retain archived copies of your User Content."
Posted by that's : #34 (in reply to #33) · reply · track
January 14, 2008 at 5:50 AM
fairly standard language used by most sites that are based on user generated content. youtube, myspace, bebo, blogger, livejournal, etc.
Posted by kts : #35 · reply · track
January 15, 2008 at 12:25 AM
This article definitely brings up a good point, but as many other commenters have noted, this is certainly not limited to facebook. Google has long been controversial for targeting its users, but it provides a much better user experience. I appreciate that the news feed adapts to my stalking habits, just as I am constantly impressed at the ads I get in my gmail. As for the Amazon thing, that's pretty standard as well- you can't get mad at facebook for what has now become standard practice.

Really, when it comes down to it, any information you put on a web page is not safe. Even if you don't share it with others, somebody else can.
Posted by Paul Knegten : #36 · reply · track
January 16, 2008 at 4:25 AM
Nice post!

Regarding the application that lets you make Facebook apps; just to clarify: it allows you to make an app that brings content or functionality from an external website into Facebook, not the other way around. Developers using the Dapper Facebook AppMaker have no access to any information about the users installing their apps (and nor do we, for that matter).
Name:
Email:
Reply to:

Describe this color in one lowercase word.
26 °F, Fair

Search

About Us

Bwog is compiled by the staff of The Blue and White, Columbia University's undergraduate magazine.

Contact Us

Please send tips to bwgossip@columbia.edu.

Questions or concerns? Email bweditors@columbia.edu.

Bwog is always looking for new writing talent. Email bwog@columbia.edu.

In Print

Our Favorite Comments

Generic Asshole: [read]
"Ew! How could you ever go to [popular Columbia spot]? It's overpriced and so fake! For REAL [service/product]..."
good analysis: [read]
"Dspar. But you know what, I think the real reason there was a crash is because there are far too few..."

Bwogroll

Technical

Our headlines are syndicated through Atom. This site is powered by the Publicate Content Management System, which is available for free.

Events

01/10/2009


Apply now and keep everyone updated on the artistic pulse of the Columbia campus! Postcrypt Art Gallery is looking for a dedicated webmaster to maintain the official Postcrypt site, www.postcrypt.info. Please e-mail jenny@postcrypt.info with your name, year and school, experience, and statement of interest.

The application deadline is January 10, 2009.


01/24/2009

Contact email: info@eastasiareview.org

The Columbia East Asia Review is currently accepting submissions for its 2009 edition. Research papers from all disciplines and majors are welcome. For more information and submission details, please visit us at www.eastasiareview.org

or e-mail us at info@eastasiareview.org. The deadline for submissions is January 24, 2009.
East Asia Review Website


01/24/2009

Contact email: helvidius@columbia.edu

Publish that senior thesis! In its 20th year of publication, the Journal of Politics & Society is inviting submissions for its 2009 edition, which will be distributed in Barnes & Noble and Borders. Please email essays to helvidius@columbia.edu or visit http://www.helvedius.org
for more info. Deadline: January 24, 2009, all disciplines welcome.


01/26/2009

Contact email: cujh@columbia.edu

Positions on the editorial board are competitive, and choices are made by a committee of current editorial board members. To apply, send the following materials to cujh@columbia.edu with the subject line: Prospective Editor Application

Include your name, year, and majors and specializations;

A list of courses taken in the history department, or related courses relevant to the field of history (Philosophy of History; Historical Sociology, etc);

A writing sample of 5 to 7 pages, double-spaced, 12 point font dealing with a historical topic; it may be an excerpt from a larger paper, include a brief abstract if necessary;

An estimate of your availability for the Spring 2009 Semester; include other commitments and positions, and your ability to commit to the extensive reading and editing that a position on the editorial board requires.

The DEADLINE for all applications is JANUARY 26th, but we encourage you to prepare your application and send it right away. Email it with writing sample attached to: cujh@columbia.edu


02/01/2009

Contact email: periwynkle@gmail.com


Do you like to read and write about books, attend literary events/exhibitions, and frequent cafés and bookstores for readings by authors and poets? If you answered yes to any part of the above question, you should write for Spectator Books! My name is Yin Yin Lu, and I am the new Spectator A&E Books Editor. There are many benefits and inimitable opportunities for Books writers besides being able to see your name in print: interviewing all sorts of published writers, from debut novelists to Nobel Peace Prize winners, attending events at the NYPL, Symphony Space, book festivals, and museums for free, and getting free review copies of books before they are released! Last semester, for instance, I interviewed Lytton Smith and Karen Russell, both published graduates of the Columbia MFA program, attended a talk with critics James Wood and Daniel Mendelsohn at the NYPL, and heard Malcolm Gladwell speak at the New Yorker Festival.

Besides being exposed to these exciting opportunities, another reason you should write for Spectator Books is that it is not a long-term commitment - you can contribute as often or as little as you like. You can start your own column, write a recurring feature, or submit an article once every few weeks (or once the entire semester). Moreover, articles are flexible in terms of length and style, depending on whether they are features, reviews, or pieces for the Eye (Spectator's weekly arts and features magazine). Or you can post reviews of any length or style anytime you want on Spectacle, A&E's new and amazing blog.

There really are no obligations to being a Spec Books writer besides actually writing the articles that you want to. I will be sending e-mails with pitches and other information every week, and holding biweekly meetings at the Spec office, but those are not mandatory and are just an opportunity for me to assign pitches and meet my writers.

Completely enticed? Mildly interested? Still uncertain and would like more information? Whatever the case, e-mail me at periwynkle@gmail.com.


02/09/2009

Contact email: cufilmproductions@columbia.edu

Columbia Undergraduate Film Productions is launching our inaugural Production Season to write and produce original short films for our Film Festival!

CUFP Production Season will consist of intensive Screenwriters' Workshops and Directors' Workshops to offer you full creative and logistic support from your peers as you make your films on campus! We are looking for talented writers and directors who are passionate about film to create fresh, interesting material for our film festival.

Ideal candidates will be enthusiastic about film, dedicated to the workshop process, and excited to work on short films in a CUFP workshop setting. Workshops will be late Sunday afternoons and some Monday evenings.

The DEADLINE for Writers' Applications is Friday January 23.
The DEADLINE for Directors' Applications is Monday February 9

All Applicants: Send an e-mail with your name, e-mail, phone number, and school and class information to CUFPproductionseason@gmail.com. Please write a short personal statement (why are you interested in CUFP Production Season? How will you benefit from the workshop process?). Make sure to include all relevant experience with film and writing and/or directing.

**Writers: Please attach a screenwriting sample in Microsoft Word format. Writing sample should be maximum 5 pgs and should give us an idea of your narrative style and genre interest. It does not have to be the short film you will work on in workshop, but if it is not please include pitches/ideas for a short film you would like to workshop.


02/15/2009

Contact email: rhapsody@columbia.edu


Rhapsody in Blue, Columbia's urban affairs journal, having successfully, if belatedly gotten its first semester magazines in hand, is going to try again.

We're back to North America this semester. We need pitches from you. We want thoughtful, interesting, fun pieces that say something about cities. What are you interested in writing about? The first step is to send us a pitch--a paragraph about what you want to talk about, how will you do it? Pitches are due February 15. You'll hear from us if it's a go and drafts due a month later.

Old issues are on our website if you'd like to see more. Great opportunity to publish ideas from class, etc.

Send an email by us with any questions. Our FIRST MEETING for anyone interested in learning more about writing, editing, web or layout will be Wed, JAN 28, at 7:30, Broadway Piano Lounge. Also stay tuned for the study abroad blog, which should be going somewhere this semester. Let us know if you're interested in that as well.


01/6/2010

Contact email: bwog@columbia.edu

Email your event ads to bwog@columbia.edu.


Lost and Found

Lost (or found) an item? Email bwog@columbia.edu.