It's Winter Break! Bwog will be moving in slow motion.

Joseph Massad: The Sequel?

As one commenter pointed out, this week's New York Magazine Daily Intelligencer section features a short piece that references an article in the Chronicle of Higher Education that speculates that Joseph Massad might be up for a second round of tenure review. Both the New York piece and the Chronicle piece have no on-the-record information to indicate such, though Columbia PR director cryptically explained that "it is consistent with our review process that cases sometimes extend beyond a single academic year or committee." In addition, the Chronicle piece quotes Cary Nelson, president of the American Association of University Professors, as saying "that while it is 'highly unusual' for a university to establish a second ad hoc review committee, 'it seems to me a good thing in this case, if questions have been raised about the decision making.'"

According to the Chronicle article -- which is only able to be read with a subscription but was luckily forwarded to Bwog in full by tipster David Judd -- "[Alan Brinkley's] decision [to deny Massad tenure] followed what professors describe as a narrow [3-2] vote in favor of Mr. Massad by an ad hoc committee of five scholars who judged his tenure file. When the provost subsequently rejected the bid, professors say, the decision prompted an angry letter from senior faculty members at Columbia who support Mr. Massad. They apparently have persuaded the provost to reconsider the case and give the professor the unusual opportunity of a second chance at tenure at Columbia."


Posted by Little Liverbird : #1 · reply · track
June 2, 2008 at 1:48 PM
Not THIS again...
Posted by Or should I say... : #2 · reply · track
June 2, 2008 at 2:58 PM
The SEQuel???
Posted by AIPACman : #3 · reply · track
June 2, 2008 at 4:22 PM
Haha, the vast Israeli Lobby conspiracy strikes again! Prepare for the return of The David Project!
Posted by any columbia student : #4 · reply · track
June 2, 2008 at 5:31 PM
can access the article through lexis-nexis
Posted by hmmm... : #5 · reply · track
June 2, 2008 at 9:13 PM
This is coming from a guy who dislikes Massas on a personal level so deeply that I cannot stand to even be in the same room with his high-handed, bloated ego. That being said, the man has written some damn good books and probably does deserve a fair shake at tenure. Of course...a lot of profs who deserve tenure don't get it. I'm thinking of three at Columbia recently...5 points if you can guess them.
Posted by What a travesty : #6 · reply · track
June 3, 2008 at 1:16 AM (from campus)
that this man is getting a second shot at tenure. Giving him the Trilling was purely a political move. This is an academic so fully wrapped up in Said-ian thought that he serves up apologetics for the scandalous crimes of the Egyptian government against gays. This is the professor implicated in a scandal of violating academic freedom -- so much so that he had to hide out for a year. This is a man with a supremely off-putting ego.

It is certainly no wonder that MEALAC (and many other areas of the humanities) are in the toilet. When Columbia gets its head out of its proverbial ass, it might realize that it employs a bunch of hacks in place of true scholars.
Posted by CU Librarian : #7 · reply · track
June 3, 2008 at 2:51 PM (from campus)
"According to the Chronicle article -- which is only able to be read with a subscription but was luckily forwarded to Bwog in full by tipster David Judd --"

Columbia has a subscription to the online Chronicle, look it up in CLIO, or use this link to connect: [external link to www.columbia.edu]
Posted by Eric Zarahn : #8 · reply · track
June 4, 2008 at 6:07 PM (from campus)
Joseph Massad has made his Columbia career based on the assertion that Israel is "a racist state". This, while the Arabs have en masse pledged to destroy Israel because it is a non-Arab, Jewish homeland. And this also while he ignores that the Arab nations are racist within their borders, having expelled Jews, preventing Israelis from visiting there, producing and internationally disseminating genocidal propaganda materials (like the "Protocols of Zion" and "Mein Kampf" along with countless sermons, pamphlets, and symposia), and often having the racial designation "Arab" in their country names. He also rarely discusses the history of the Arab treatment of the Jewish people. Is it not amazing that to Massad the 1948 War, in which the Arabs tried their best (at the time) to slaughter all the Israelis in their tiny new state, is deemed irrelevant? How has he been able to spit on truth so unabashedly? If he gets tenure, then we know that racism and historical revisionism is condoned, nurtured, and rewarded by Columbia.
Posted by ......... : #9 · reply · track
June 4, 2008 at 11:43 PM
Clearly, it was his stellar scholarship that propelled Columbia to give him a second tenure review. Politics had nothing to do with it... After all, not one of the countless of professors that have been denied tenure before could even approach this man's academic greatness.
Posted by Matt : #10 · reply · track
June 9, 2008 at 2:00 AM
A broad cross section of Massad’s academic works:

[external link to en.wikiquote.org]

As you can see, this is somebody whose intellectual mentors on subjects like the Middle East and the Holocaust include “academic giants” like Paul Findley, Lenni Brenner, and Norman Finkelstein. That Massad would even cite such non-accredited fringe individuals in academic journal articles boggles the mind. That he would opine about subjects about which he has no understanding (like the Talmud) is stunning. And his use of inflammatory but fraudulent quotations of certain prime ministers (and his refusal even to correct the record explicitly) belies his claims of academic professionalism.

The fact that anyone is seriously even considering granting Massad a tenure position at an Ivy League university is almost too absurd to imagine, and is clearly a function of ideological politics. And yet people are suggesting with a straight face that he is being _denied_ tenure because of politics? Absurd. Has anyone considered the possibility that Massad is just a second-rate, ideological, academic wannabe who is only where he is right now because of academic back-scratching and because his views happen to be in vogue these days?

And this is how he behaves _before_ getting tenure. Anyone wish to imagine what a headache he’d be for the university _after_ getting tenure?

Posted by David : #11 (in reply to #10) · reply · track
June 11, 2008 at 1:39 AM
In the site you link to, Matt, Finkelstein is only "cited" in the context of Massad favorably reviewing his book. The idea that everyone whose book I favorably review becomes my "intellectual mentor" is crazy; and if he is invited to review his book in an academic journal, obviously it is acceptable to cite him in that academic journal article.

Findley is cited once, in the context of alleged influences of the so-called "Israel lobby" on Congress. Since Findley is a former congressman, his evidence is perfectly reasonable for Massad to cite, and it does not make him Massad's "intellectual mentor".

None of this is to say that Massad should get tenure, but having seen the poverty of your argument against him I am more inclined in his favor than I was previously.
Posted by David : #12 (in reply to #8) · reply · track
June 11, 2008 at 1:49 AM
Eric:

I'm a little confused by your argument. Are you suggesting that the undeniable fact that Arab states are racist somehow proves that Israel is not herself racist? How does that follow?

Or are you suggesting that Massad (a Palestinian-American, after all) is racist for concentrating on Israeli racism to the exclusion of Arab racism? Are Jewish-American academics equally racist if they concentrate their fire on Arab racism to the exclusion of Israeli, or does this only work in one direction?
Posted by Matt : #13 · reply · track
June 11, 2008 at 10:21 AM
Massad learned what he knows about the Israel lobby in large part from Paul Findley's book from the 1980s, a perfectly adequate definition of intellectual mentorship. Ditto for Brenner regarding alleged "collaboration" between Zionism and Nazism, whose books from the 1980s Massad repeatedly cites in several papers as his main source on the subject, calling the books "classics". Neither of these individuals are academically accredited in any way, and they are both way out on the fringes of contemporary discourse. This is poor academic professionalism on his part.

It was probably incorrect to lump Finkelstein in their with Massad's intellectual mentors. I must say, however, that when Massad criticizes Finkelstein in his paper "Deconstructing Holocaust Consciousness" for being _too_ Zionist, that tells you something.
Posted by Matt : #14 · reply · track
June 11, 2008 at 10:30 AM
Nor, David, have you addressed any of the other points I brought up or that emerge from the Wikiquote page. His charges that the majority of Jews in the world are guilty of "Jewish supremacism", his ignorant statements about the Talmud or about American Jewish culture not existing in anything beyond name, his willingness to use inflammatory quotations of questionable veracity that he would later quietly remove without comment when he discovered they were fraudulent, among many other things. None of this is an attack on his ideology per se, but on his methods and professionalism.
Name:
Email:
Reply to:

Describe this color in one lowercase word.
31 °F, Partly Cloudy

Search

About Us

Bwog is compiled by the staff of The Blue and White, Columbia University's undergraduate magazine.

Contact Us

Please send tips to bwgossip@columbia.edu.

Questions or concerns? Email bweditors@columbia.edu.

Bwog is always looking for new writing talent. Email bwog@columbia.edu.

In Print

Our Favorite Comments

Generic Asshole: [read]
"Ew! How could you ever go to [popular Columbia spot]? It's overpriced and so fake! For REAL [service/product]..."
good analysis: [read]
"Dspar. But you know what, I think the real reason there was a crash is because there are far too few..."

Bwogroll

Technical

Our headlines are syndicated through Atom. This site is powered by the Publicate Content Management System, which is available for free.

Events

01/10/2009


Apply now and keep everyone updated on the artistic pulse of the Columbia campus! Postcrypt Art Gallery is looking for a dedicated webmaster to maintain the official Postcrypt site, www.postcrypt.info. Please e-mail jenny@postcrypt.info with your name, year and school, experience, and statement of interest.

The application deadline is January 10, 2009.


01/24/2009

Contact email: info@eastasiareview.org

The Columbia East Asia Review is currently accepting submissions for its 2009 edition. Research papers from all disciplines and majors are welcome. For more information and submission details, please visit us at www.eastasiareview.org

or e-mail us at info@eastasiareview.org. The deadline for submissions is January 24, 2009.
East Asia Review Website


01/24/2009

Contact email: helvidius@columbia.edu

Publish that senior thesis! In its 20th year of publication, the Journal of Politics & Society is inviting submissions for its 2009 edition, which will be distributed in Barnes & Noble and Borders. Please email essays to helvidius@columbia.edu or visit http://www.helvedius.org
for more info. Deadline: January 24, 2009, all disciplines welcome.


01/26/2009

Contact email: cujh@columbia.edu

Positions on the editorial board are competitive, and choices are made by a committee of current editorial board members. To apply, send the following materials to cujh@columbia.edu with the subject line: Prospective Editor Application

Include your name, year, and majors and specializations;

A list of courses taken in the history department, or related courses relevant to the field of history (Philosophy of History; Historical Sociology, etc);

A writing sample of 5 to 7 pages, double-spaced, 12 point font dealing with a historical topic; it may be an excerpt from a larger paper, include a brief abstract if necessary;

An estimate of your availability for the Spring 2009 Semester; include other commitments and positions, and your ability to commit to the extensive reading and editing that a position on the editorial board requires.

The DEADLINE for all applications is JANUARY 26th, but we encourage you to prepare your application and send it right away. Email it with writing sample attached to: cujh@columbia.edu


02/01/2009

Contact email: periwynkle@gmail.com


Do you like to read and write about books, attend literary events/exhibitions, and frequent cafés and bookstores for readings by authors and poets? If you answered yes to any part of the above question, you should write for Spectator Books! My name is Yin Yin Lu, and I am the new Spectator A&E Books Editor. There are many benefits and inimitable opportunities for Books writers besides being able to see your name in print: interviewing all sorts of published writers, from debut novelists to Nobel Peace Prize winners, attending events at the NYPL, Symphony Space, book festivals, and museums for free, and getting free review copies of books before they are released! Last semester, for instance, I interviewed Lytton Smith and Karen Russell, both published graduates of the Columbia MFA program, attended a talk with critics James Wood and Daniel Mendelsohn at the NYPL, and heard Malcolm Gladwell speak at the New Yorker Festival.

Besides being exposed to these exciting opportunities, another reason you should write for Spectator Books is that it is not a long-term commitment - you can contribute as often or as little as you like. You can start your own column, write a recurring feature, or submit an article once every few weeks (or once the entire semester). Moreover, articles are flexible in terms of length and style, depending on whether they are features, reviews, or pieces for the Eye (Spectator's weekly arts and features magazine). Or you can post reviews of any length or style anytime you want on Spectacle, A&E's new and amazing blog.

There really are no obligations to being a Spec Books writer besides actually writing the articles that you want to. I will be sending e-mails with pitches and other information every week, and holding biweekly meetings at the Spec office, but those are not mandatory and are just an opportunity for me to assign pitches and meet my writers.

Completely enticed? Mildly interested? Still uncertain and would like more information? Whatever the case, e-mail me at periwynkle@gmail.com.


02/09/2009

Contact email: cufilmproductions@columbia.edu

Columbia Undergraduate Film Productions is launching our inaugural Production Season to write and produce original short films for our Film Festival!

CUFP Production Season will consist of intensive Screenwriters' Workshops and Directors' Workshops to offer you full creative and logistic support from your peers as you make your films on campus! We are looking for talented writers and directors who are passionate about film to create fresh, interesting material for our film festival.

Ideal candidates will be enthusiastic about film, dedicated to the workshop process, and excited to work on short films in a CUFP workshop setting. Workshops will be late Sunday afternoons and some Monday evenings.

The DEADLINE for Writers' Applications is Friday January 23.
The DEADLINE for Directors' Applications is Monday February 9

All Applicants: Send an e-mail with your name, e-mail, phone number, and school and class information to CUFPproductionseason@gmail.com. Please write a short personal statement (why are you interested in CUFP Production Season? How will you benefit from the workshop process?). Make sure to include all relevant experience with film and writing and/or directing.

**Writers: Please attach a screenwriting sample in Microsoft Word format. Writing sample should be maximum 5 pgs and should give us an idea of your narrative style and genre interest. It does not have to be the short film you will work on in workshop, but if it is not please include pitches/ideas for a short film you would like to workshop.


02/15/2009

Contact email: rhapsody@columbia.edu


Rhapsody in Blue, Columbia's urban affairs journal, having successfully, if belatedly gotten its first semester magazines in hand, is going to try again.

We're back to North America this semester. We need pitches from you. We want thoughtful, interesting, fun pieces that say something about cities. What are you interested in writing about? The first step is to send us a pitch--a paragraph about what you want to talk about, how will you do it? Pitches are due February 15. You'll hear from us if it's a go and drafts due a month later.

Old issues are on our website if you'd like to see more. Great opportunity to publish ideas from class, etc.

Send an email by us with any questions. Our FIRST MEETING for anyone interested in learning more about writing, editing, web or layout will be Wed, JAN 28, at 7:30, Broadway Piano Lounge. Also stay tuned for the study abroad blog, which should be going somewhere this semester. Let us know if you're interested in that as well.


01/6/2010

Contact email: bwog@columbia.edu

Email your event ads to bwog@columbia.edu.


Lost and Found

Lost (or found) an item? Email bwog@columbia.edu.