Of Hamantaschen and Controversy

Bnai Haman is going to have the most quasi-topical Purim ever. But first, some background: Bnai Haman is an activist group formed as a response to Bollinger, Bulliet, and Coatworth's invitation of Iranian President Ahmadinejad to speak at Columbia—an invitation which in their opinion never should have been extended. Purim is the Jewish holiday celebrating the Jews' escape from Haman's plot (yes, as in "Bnai Haman") to slaughter all Jews living in the Persian Empire.

Which brings us to Bnai Haman's Purim celebration, which will be Ahmadinejad-themed this year. Says a Bnai Haman spokeswoman: "And just as Haman found those in ancient Persia who would listen to his incitements, so too did Columbia University provide a platform for Ahmadinejad to espouse Israel's destruction to a global media audience."

Party-goers will dress as Bollinger, Bulliet, Ahmadinejad and Coatsworth. Perhaps the role of Esther can be re-interpreted as a certain nasally female translator?


- JNW


Posted by Sadia : #1 · reply · track
February 20, 2008 at 1:06 PM (from campus)
What is that photo of?
Posted by Juli (Site staff): #2 (in reply to #1) · reply · track
February 20, 2008 at 1:07 PM (from campus)
Hamantaschen
Posted by ... : #3 · reply · track
February 20, 2008 at 1:09 PM
Wasn't it Cyrus, King of Persia, who freed the Jews from Babylon and allowed them to return to Israel?

Why does everything at this school have to focus on the bad side of Iran?
Posted by Anonymous : #4 (in reply to #3) · reply · track
February 20, 2008 at 1:23 PM (from campus)
Better yet, why does one group who are only a group because of shared crazy-ass mythological stories get to have an effect on what should be a secular institution?

I guess I'm just mad because Krishna really disapproves of those who eat meat. You're all a bunch of sinners.
Posted by Woohoo : #5 · reply · track
February 20, 2008 at 1:24 PM (from campus)
"And just as Haman found those in ancient Persia who would listen to his incitements, so too did Columbia University provide a platform for Ahmadinejad to espouse Israel's destruction to a global media audience."

And proud of it.
Posted by why : #6 · reply · track
February 20, 2008 at 1:31 PM (from campus)
why is a mexican making that hamantaschen
Posted by Cyrus : #7 (in reply to #3) · reply · track
February 20, 2008 at 1:38 PM
You're so ridiculous you make me laugh... Incidentally, do you know that the Iranian government is seeking to destroy King Cyrus' tomb, because they wish to erase their "anti-Islamic" past?
Posted by Armin Rosen : #8 · reply · track
February 20, 2008 at 1:39 PM (from campus)
Actually, Bnei Haman means "sons of Haman," as in the 12 sons of Haman who are hung at the end of Esther as a reprisal for their father's plot against the Jews.

It's an odd reference, since the sons are basically blameless people, and the celebratory bloodbath in the last chapter of Esther is among the least politically correct passages in the entire Tanakh. It's a pretty sinister name for a group, as it refers to a prototypical moment of Jews going off the deep-end...although maybe they were going for irony?
Posted by Armin Rosen : #9 · reply · track
February 20, 2008 at 1:40 PM (from campus)
And by they I mean Bnei Haman. Not the Jews of ancient Persia.
Posted by i miss : #10 · reply · track
February 20, 2008 at 1:43 PM (from campus)
catholic grade school.
Posted by k. friedman : #11 · reply · track
February 20, 2008 at 1:56 PM (from campus)
one thing's for sure, they aren't making jews like jesus anymore.
Posted by Shira : #12 · reply · track
February 20, 2008 at 2:15 PM
I'm confused--is Bnai Haman actually doing this at Columbia? Is this campus news, or just wingnut news peripherally related to Columbia issues? I agree with what Armin wrote about the sinister nature of the group's name, but from what I've read on their website it doesn't seem like they're going for irony at all. This post would benefit from an update explaining whether anyone currently on campus (that is, other than "Columbia University alumni and other concerned citizens") is actually involved, because as it is, the whole thing seems pretty dodgy. Say what you will about Ahmedenijad's speech, but Bnai Haman spouts a lot of vitriol and I'm sure that Columbia groups also holding Purim celebrations would rather create their own agendas (if a holiday party really needs to have an agenda...). Just saying, a little clarification would go a long way.
Posted by The Jewish community : #13 · reply · track
February 20, 2008 at 3:02 PM (from campus)
at this school has just become unpleasant. I feel very alienated by this high-octane, venom-spewing, intolerant sort of atmosphere. It's really a shame.
Posted by Fed up : #14 · reply · track
February 20, 2008 at 3:06 PM
That's it. I've had enough of Bwog. So long.
Posted by Shira : #15 (in reply to #13) · reply · track
February 20, 2008 at 3:16 PM
While I don't consider myself to be a part of it, I don't think Columbia's Jewish community should have to take the blame for this organization. This post REALLY needs a disclaimer. Couldn't you tell that that wasn't a real press release? It's too hateful to be funny. Come on, Bwog!
Posted by Bwog : #16 (in reply to #14) · reply · track
February 20, 2008 at 3:39 PM (from campus)
Bye!
Posted by Cloning : #17 (in reply to #11) · reply · track
February 20, 2008 at 3:55 PM (from campus)
Well...depending on who you talk to, do they make *anybody* like Jesus anymore?
Posted by bible police : #18 · reply · track
February 20, 2008 at 5:48 PM (from campus)
Sorry Armin, but Haman had only 10 sons. This...is very important...
Posted by Observer : #19 · reply · track
February 20, 2008 at 6:04 PM
There are people on this campus that still have their panties in bunches over the Ahmadinejad speech?

If you're that intolerant, I hope you do us all a favor and transfer.
Posted by Observer : #20 · reply · track
February 20, 2008 at 6:09 PM
Just to follow up --

I'm Jewish, and (much like what #13 said) I think what this small vocal minority of ill-informed and mostly afraid small-minded Jews on our campus makes us all look really, really bad.
Posted by ... : #21 (in reply to #7) · reply · track
February 20, 2008 at 6:35 PM
Incidentally, I know that. I wasn't trying to defend this government. I was just defending the people's culture and history which is a completely different thing.

I was just trying to point out a positive moment in Iranian history. But I'm sorry for pointing that out since it's easier to dehumanize a people when you don't consider both sides.
Posted by EAL : #22 (in reply to #20) · reply · track
February 20, 2008 at 9:14 PM (from campus)
Yes, just like that tiny minority of hunger strikers, Ruddites, and other assorted people who will protest anything makes this University look bad.
Posted by Jimmy Donuts : #23 · reply · track
February 20, 2008 at 9:45 PM
I'm Jewish as well, and much like #13 and #20 said, it is a bloody tragedy that a small bunch of apikorsim and mamzerim such as those of Bnai Haman actually walk around Columbia.

These people are an embarrassment to the community, are guilty of the grave sin of chilul hashem, and are the reason I steer clear of the Hillel on this campus.

Mamzerim, that's what they all are.
Posted by ummm : #24 · reply · track
February 21, 2008 at 12:40 AM
just pointing out that it doesn't seem like they're at columbia at all...
Posted by Incidentally... : #25 (in reply to #21) · reply · track
February 21, 2008 at 12:54 AM
Over the years, I have known many Iranians personally, both Muslim and Jewish. So I (in addition to most of those who despise the Iranian regime) know that Iranians have a history and a culture. In light of their history, the current state of affairs is all the more ironic.
Posted by Hello. : #26 (in reply to #23) · reply · track
February 21, 2008 at 12:56 AM
I'm Jewish as well, and I just wanted to tell you that you are the Mamzer. You know it too.
Posted by you : #27 (in reply to #26) · reply · track
February 21, 2008 at 2:42 PM
=ben zonah.
Posted by A-Jad/Bollinger : #28 · reply · track
February 23, 2008 at 1:55 PM
Hey, send us your photo and we'll wear your mask as well. You can see a Bollinger mask at www.leebollinger-bnaihaman.com. Even Haman had his Jewish supporters. So why not you?
Posted by A-Jad/Bollinger : #29 (in reply to #20) · reply · track
February 23, 2008 at 2:00 PM
As a member of Bnai Haman, "this small vocal minority of ill-informed and mostly afraid small-minded Jews on our campus makes us all look really, really bad" let me assure you of two things.

1. Not all of our members are Jewish.

2. You look plenty bad all on your own. You don't need us to help.
Name:
Email:
Reply to:

Describe this color in one lowercase word.
78 °F, Mostly Cloudy

About Us

Bwog is compiled by the staff of The Blue and White, Columbia University's undergraduate magazine.

Contact Us

Please send tips to tips@bwog.net.

Questions or concerns? Email editors@bwog.net.

Bwog is always looking for new writing talent. Email contribute@bwog.net.

In Print

Our Favorite Comments

5 bucks says: [read]
"That once she deals with Facilities, she'll give up on SPEW."
Ahaha: [read]
"Funny mental image of an old man with a walker yelling "BWOG" in that comment"

Bwogroll

Technical

Our headlines are syndicated through Atom. This site is powered by a modified version of the Publicate Content Management System, which is available for free.

Events

07/15/2009

Contact email: opinion@columbiaspectator.com

Spectator is now accepting applications for fall 2009 opinion columns. Write to opinion@columbiaspectator.com or go to to obtain an application. The application deadline is July 15, 2009.

Spectator accepts columnist applications from students at any undergraduate school affiliated with Columbia University. Columns are published every two weeks, and writers are expected to edit with an opinion page editor before publication.
http://www.columbiaspectator.com/about


01/6/2010

Contact email: events@bwog.net

Please provide the following:

Title
Location
Date/Time
Description
Contact email
Contact website
Logo/flyer image

We're excited to announce that we can now include images in line with your event listing! These can link to anything on the web. For example, you could include your organization's logo and have it link to your website. Or, you could have us post a thumbnail of your flyer and have clicking on it reveal the larger one.

Please do give us a few days' notice- our inboxes fill up quickly every day, so it may take a little while for your event to be posted.


Lost and Found

Lost (or found) an item? Email tips@bwog.net.