When college-authored Young Adult Chick Lit scandals emerge, who better to comment than Barnard '08's own Robyn Schneider. Herself the author of two forthcoming Young Adult books, Robyn (B&W profile) is taking it personally.
Kaavya Viswanathan must have an industrial strength photographic memory.
Why, you ask? Because only someone with a mind like a steal (ha) trap
could unknowingly plagiarize Megan McCafferty's novels more than forty
times and do so unconsciously.
McCafferty's publisher, Steve Ross, called the Harvard sophomore's debut
novel, already a New York Times bestseller, "Nothing less than an act of
literary identity theft." He claims that it is "inconceivable" that
Kaavya was not aware of what she was doing.
But what I think is that Kaavya still isn't aware of what she's done.
Many of the litblogs I read are blaming Kaavya's plagiarism not on her
lack of morals but on her age. Apparently, if you give a teen a book
deal, they won't know better than to plagiarize. It's sentiments like
this that make me want to gouge my name out of the LA Times article that
featured Viswanathan and myself as young chick lit novelists. Do I have
to listen to sweeping generalizations that all young writers don't take
stealing seriously because our generation downloads illegal music files?
Just because James Frey lied doesn't mean I automatically assume all
memoirists are "embellishing" the hell out of their unremarkable lives.
And just because Kaavya apparently plagiarized doesn't mean that all young
novelists should be blamed. Can the world please leave the rest of us out
of this?